We have done our own series of reviews discussing the Xperia X1 vs the HTC Touch Pro, and now the Boy Genius Report has done their own version, comparing the devices on screen, keyboard, OS, battery, connectivity, speed, sexiness, navigation and finally touch.
Their conclusion was:
At the end of the day, what phone is better? Thatâ€™s the ultimate question isnâ€™t it? I personally crowned the AT&T Fuze as the best Windows Mobile device out there. Am I sticking to it? More or less, yes. Hereâ€™s whyâ€¦ The XPERIA X1 is a fantastic Windows Mobile phone. But the more we use it and evaluate it, the more we think its target market shrinks. Not so much because the device is sub-par, itâ€™s quite the opposite. Itâ€™s just that we feel the only consumers interested in the X1 will be prior Windows Mobile users that know what they are doing and know how to handle the shortcomings in WinMo. Then thereâ€™s the $800 price tag which will certainly push a huge segment of the target market away. Like real, real fast. Looking at both of them from a consumerâ€™s perspective, there really isnâ€™t any reason to not go with the Fuze. Even if youâ€™re not on AT&T, paying $500 for an unlocked unit is still better than paying $800.
The Fuze offers a much more complete experience than the X1, and that combined with the price really makes this a winner. If we eliminated price altogether, which one would we choose? Thatâ€™s really tough, folks. The fact is weâ€™d be happy with either one of them, but at this point weâ€™d probably just go ahead and choose the Fuze. Itâ€™s much more streamlined, the entire OS is cohesive in terms of what HTC has done (everything from the volume up/down screen, to the Connection Manager, to TouchFLO, to well, you get the point) and itâ€™s just an all-around more usable phone out of the box. If you want to man up and get your hands dirty with customizing the X1 and making it suit your needs better, more power to you. Weâ€™ve pretty much raped this handset and got it up to snuff, we just donâ€™t think that many people want to be bothered with doing that. Not with Android, Symbian, BlackBerry and the iPhone around.
To see how they came to this conclusion read the full comparative review here.